Bringing you the "Good News" of Jesus Christ and His Church While PROMOTING CATHOLIC Apologetic Support groups loyal to the Holy Father and Church's magisterium
Home About
AskACatholic.com
What's New? Resources The Church Family Life Mass and
Adoration
Ask A Catholic
Knowledge base
AskACatholic Disclaimer
Search the
AskACatholic Database
Donate and
Support our work
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
New Questions
Cool Catholic Videos
About Saints
Disciplines and Practices for distinct Church seasons
Purgatory and Indulgences
About the Holy Mass
About Mary
Searching and Confused
Contemplating becoming a Catholic or Coming home
Homosexual and Gender Issues
Life, Dating, and Family
No Salvation Outside the Church
Sacred Scripture
non-Catholic Cults
Justification and Salvation
The Pope and Papacy
The Sacraments
Relationships and Marriage situations
Specific people, organizations and events
back
Doctrine and Teachings
Specific Practices
Church Internals
Church History

Joanne Groshardt wrote:

Hi, guys —

Jesus was born a Jew. He promoted God, being devoted to God and charity.

  • Was He a Jew or Christian when he walked and talked through the towns?

Jesus died and His Apostles continued doing his work.

  • Did the Apostles perform miracles?
  • Were they trying to convert people to be Jewish or Christian?
  • Where did Christianity start?

I don't understand Jesus being a Jew and now, we are Christians. My Jewish friend said she thought of Jesus as a prophet — or some similar name.

  • He did perform miracles in front of people, so what do they think Jesus was?
Joanne G.
  { Was Jesus a Jew or Christian when He walked through the towns and did He disavow being Jewish? }

John replied:

Hi Joanne,

Thank you for your questions. 

I'm going to answer your questions. However, in addition, I'm going to encourage you to start reading the Holy Bible, and I'll give you the Books that answer your questions.

Let's start with the fact that Jesus was born a Hebrew, from the Tribe of Judah, of the Royal line of King David.  He fulfilled hundreds of prophecies about the Messiah, written hundreds and even thousands of years before He entered creation, taking on the form of a Man.  Jesus is the Eternal Living Word of God the Father.  He's the Second person of the Holy Trinity.  He always existed, along with the Father, and the Holy Spirit.

We read this in the first Chapter of the Gospel of John.   He was Incarnate by the Holy Spirit and born of the Virgin Mary, and became Man.  He was God before He was Incarnate in Mary's Womb. In Mary's womb He took on Human Flesh and became Man, being both 100% God and 100% Man.  

He came to fully reveal God to the World, to Proclaim that Gospel. That is the Good News, that we can be saved from sin and death, because of His Sacrifice on the Cross, His Resurrection, and Ascension back to Heaven. He will return to raise all the dead and judge us at the end of time. 

So, His mission wasn't just about promoting God and Charity.  He came to save us from our sin. His Salvation is a free gift of His Grace, that we access by Faith In Him.  We cannot earn that Salvation, but at the same time we have free will. Hence, we must cooperate with the Grace He bestows on us.  We can also choose to reject His Grace and Mercy, in which case we won't be saved.  This is all distilled in John 3:16. For God so loved the World that He gave His only Begotten Son, that whosoever believes in Him, shall not perish, but have eternal life.

Ethnically Jesus remains a Jew just like His Blessed Mother, and the Apostles.  But He came to fulfill the law and thus Judaism. But He tells us in Matthew 16:18, and in the following verses, that He intends to build a Church.  This Church not only would include Jews that believed in Him, but the non-Jews. We can see this happening in the entire Book of the Acts of the Apostle. St. Paul explains this . . . calling it a great Mystery, in His epistle to the Ephesians 3.  He unites both Jews and Gentiles into one new man, His Body, the Church. 

So, Christianity, is the fulfillment of Biblical Judaism.  Hence, the Church, more specifically the Catholic Church, is the New Israel.  Within the Church there are people of all ethnicities, including Jews.  That doesn't mean that ethnic Jews, are no longer Israel, but that they are no-longer following Biblical Judaism, which is fulfilled in the Church.   I'm not saying that all current Jews, can't be saved. God can save anyone, but the normal means of salvation is found in the Catholic Church. All Salvation comes from Jesus Christ and somehow through His Body, which is the Church.

After Jesus rose from the dead, He spent 40 days with His Apostles and Disciples. At which point He ascended to Heaven. Ten days later, He sent the Holy Spirit, to indwell the Church and the members of the Church.  We receive the Holy Spirit through Baptism, then again through Confirmation. This initiates us into the Body of Christ, His Church.

There was a period of time, in the very early Church, that all the believers were Jewish. Later in the Book of Acts (Chapter 10) we see that God made it evident to the Apostles that they should also preach the Gospel to non-Jews (called Gentiles).  Throughout the Book of Acts we see the Apostles performing Miracles, we also see ordinary Christians being vehicles through which Christ performs miracles and that still happens today.    Even in the 4 Gospels we read that Jesus sent out His Apostles 2 by 2 to preach, teach, and perform miracles. They healed the sick, they cast out demons, and in the Book of Acts we read that they raised the dead.  All of this is only possible through the power of the Holy Spirit, who indwells in the Church and Her members.

At first the followers of Christ were called "The Way."  Later we read in Acts, that in the city of Antioch, we were first called Christians. Literally this means “little Christs”.  Christ is the Greek word for Messiah. So, Christians are little Messiahs.  The word Church is the Greek word "Ecclesia". We get terms like Ecclesial, or Ecclesiology from it.  It literally means "The Called Out" or "the Called-Out People of God." This is precisely what Hebrews were in the Old Testament.
 
We read in Acts that at first there was some confusion and controversy. Some of the Apostles believed that in order for a Gentile to become a Christian, they first had to become Jews and then follow the entirety of the Ceremonial Jewish Law and Temple Worship.  This included all the men becoming circumcised to become initiated.

However, it was discerned by the help of the Holy Spirit, at the Council of Jerusalem (Acts Chapter 15), that this was not necessary. 

For about 40 years, the Church existed within Judaism. It was considered a sect. It was like a gestation period for the Early Church, with Judaism serving as a womb.  But in 70 A.D., the Temple in Jerusalem was destroyed. So there were no longer daily animal sacrifices being offered for sin. They were no longer necessary, because Christ provided that only acceptable Sacrifice on the Cross. So Biblical Judaism no longer exists.  Today's ethnic Jews retain certain aspects of their ceremonial laws, but they can no longer offer sacrifices for their sins. 

There is no more Temple. They have synagogues, places of teaching. But Biblical Judaism required that these Sacrifices be done at the one Temple in Jerusalem. 

So today, we have what's called Rabbinic Judaism.  A system designed by Rabbis (Teachers) as opposed to the system of worship designed by God.    Biblical Judaism is found in the Catholic Church, because at Mass, the very same Sacrifice, offered once for all by Jesus, on the Cross of Calvary, is made present on the Altar. When we as Catholics attend Mass, they are made Mystically Present at Calvary to unite ourselves to the Sacrifice of Jesus, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sins of the world.  He is the Passover Lamb... indeed Good Friday took place during Passover. And just as the Passover Lamb had to be eaten for the Sacrifice to be complete, so too we consume Jesus Himself, when we receive Communion. 

Now as an aside, this Sacrifice of the Mass, is also found in the Orthodox Church. The split between Catholics and Orthodox is one that revolves around Church Government. So, the Orthodox, are in an imperfect connection to the Catholic Church. 

Other Protestant Christians, no longer have a legitimate and valid priesthood, so they don't have the Mass. They have services. Even still, they are in a less perfect communion with the Catholic Church. They are Christians because of their Baptism and faith in Christ. So, in a very loose sense, all Christians are somehow part of the Catholic Church, but not fully.

The bottom line is that Jesus was and remains ethnically Jewish. But Judaism is 100% percent fulfilled in Christianity. The current Jews (unless they've converted) are trying to live in the Old Covenant, but they have no means to fulfill its requirements.

I would encourage you to start reading the Bible, beginning with the New Testaments.  Start with Matthew, then read the Book of Acts, then the letters or epistles that follow.  In between, you can go back and read the other three Gospels.   I'm assuming you're Catholic, so pay attention to the readings at Mass. Arrive early and read them first. Then listen attentively to them and then pay attention to the Homily.  Pay attention to the words of the various prayers we say and the prayers that are only said by the priest.

I hope this helps,

John DiMascio

Bob replied:

Dear Joanne,

Just to add one point to answer your final question, paraphrasing,

  • “What do Jews think of Jesus?, someone who is a prophet — or some similar name?”  

It depends.  

  • Some Jews regard Jesus in that way, a good man who was inflated into something more by his followers.  
  • But others regard him with serious disdain, as the Talmud condemns him in the most vile way, along with the Blessed Mother, which assertions I will not recount here.  So Talmudic Jews often don’t hide their contempt, which has sometimes turned into outward conflicts with Christians in the Holy Land.  For this we must pray.

C. S. Lewis gave us the challenge: Jesus was either:

  1. a liar
  2. a lunatic or . . .
  3. telling the truth, He is The Lord.

We are not left with the option to:

  • ignore Him
  • patronize Him, or
  • dismiss His claims as posthumous creations of quixotic followers.  

No, Jesus made real claims, and the evidence of his life, attested to by friends and foes, supports His claims.  Sadly, the division between believers and unbelievers will continue to the bitter end.

Peace,

Bob Kirby

Joanne replied:

Hi, guys —

  • But did Jesus disavow being Jewish to start Christianity?
  • Did He say His religious background of a Jew was wrong?
  • Did Christianity start the moment He started to speak?

I don't quite understand His transition.

  • Did He call His teachings Christianity?

Thanks for your reading time,

Joanne

John replied:

Joanne,

  1. Judaism as we now know it did not exist at the time of Jesus.  So, you're trying to compare apples and rusty razor blades.

  2. Judaism was not actually ever a Religion.  God instead established a system of worship, through Moses.  This system included 613 commandments and requirements of animal sacrifice which first took place in the Tent of Meeting and then In the Temple Jerusalem.  Rabbis had added layers of interpretations, which were essentially additional laws. 

    These Sacrifices all pointed to Jesus, who would fulfill them all with His Sacrifice.

  3. Jesus never condemned what He, Himself established.  He fulfilled it.  Therefore, the Temple was destroyed, because there was no longer a need for these Sacrifices.

  4. To be clear, the term Jew, comes from the name of only one tribe of Israel. It is the one surviving tribe, along with some Levites.

    God chose and established a people.  He gave them a law and system of worship.  That people is called Israel.... and by ethnicity, they are Hebrews.    These people were to be light to all other nations and bring them to the knowledge of the one true God.

  5. Jesus said that He would build His Church.... which would include all people. Thus, as an Israelite, that fulfills the mandate to Israel, to bring people to the knowledge of God.

  6. As I wrote previously, Believers in Christ, were first called Christians in Antioch.  This was decades after Jesus ascended into Heaven.

    So, No, Jesus didn't call Himself a Christian.  Jesus is God . . . He's not part of a religion, which is a system of worship. Being God, He is the object of worship. And He established our Worship, by Establishing the Eucharistic Sacrifice, which fulfills the entirety of the Temple Worship practiced by the Jews.

  7. If anything, we can say that Jesus expanded Israel (or if you insist Judaism) to include all Nations into one Universal Church. He replaced the complicated sacrificial system of Israel by fulfilling it Himself in His Flesh.

  8. Jesus did not disavow His Ethnicity. He remains an ethnic Jew, and thus an Israelite. But He transformed the faith to include people from every nation and gave us perfect Worship. What Israel had was a shadow and metaphor of things to come.  Jesus completed and perfected the incomplete and perfected the imperfect. 

    Now as to the transition . . . . That's recorded primarily in the Book of Acts.   

    It's 28 short Chapters.  I suggest you read it. There was period where the Jewish believers tried to remain within Judaism. However, the Jewish leadership persecuted them and put many to death.

    Starting in the early 60s A.D., the Jews in the Holy Land started a revolt against Rome. It ended with Rome destroying Jerusalem and the Temple in 70 A.D.  Jesus predicted all this in Matthew 24 and Mark 13.  The "Jewish Christians," realized what was happening and refused to fight alongside their fellow country man.  They fled, following the instructions Jesus gave them in the aforementioned chapters.

    This sealed the separation between the Ethnic Jews and Jewish Christians.  The Jewish believers were thrown out of the synagogues, but it had been happening all along.  When a Jew came to believe in Jesus, many times their families would throw them out and considered them dead. 

    But there was a 40-year period, where God allowed the Church to remain associated with the Jews, so that those He knew would come to faith, would have the opportunity.   So, Judaism served as a sort of womb.
John
Please report any and all typos or grammatical errors.
Suggestions for this web page and the web site can be sent to Mike Humphrey
© 2012 Panoramic Sites
The Early Church Fathers Church Fathers on the Primacy of Peter. The Early Church Fathers on the Catholic Church and the term Catholic. The Early Church Fathers on the importance of the Roman Catholic Church centered in Rome.